Atheism Stack Exchange Archive

What bogus anti-theistic claims have you encountered?

What false or misleading anti-theistic claims (like the one listed here) have you encountered?

Ideally, provide a link to both an example of the claim and sources refuting it.

Answer 1351

Studies showing that atheists are smarter than theists, like the one by Kanazawa. In fact, these studies are poorly executed and don’t show conclusive results at all. Furthermore, any study measuring intelligence has to overcome some pretty high obstacles to account for local differences, inexact measures, the inherent problems of IQ testing and many other factors.

For a good refutation of such studies, see PZ Myers, and him again.

Answer 1446

The claim that the Vatican City's age of consent is 12 looks like it is bogus: What is the age of consent laws of Vatican City? [closed].

Answer 1377

Worst argument by a wide margin is the claim that Jesus never existed, or that he’s a reinvention of other dying god-men. Sorry to say this, but these claims are based on 150 year old, out-dated scholarship, and its an extremely minority opinion among historians today.

See this discussion for a detailed listing of gods presumed to be prototypes, and how they stack up against the actual myths.

Long story short: Jesus certainly existed, even if his the details of his life are lost in myth and legend.

Answer 1360

The movie Zeitgeist was full of momentarily compelling claims that where ment to be damning to some core Christian claims. It turns out most of it was bogus. The ironchariouts.org wiki has a great writeup of what was wrong with the religious part of the movie.


All content is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.